Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-206.248.102.212-20130711220058/@comment-81.219.210.91-20130805135851

Professore Saberhagen wrote:

I dislike her because she, as a heterosexual female has no place in an anime about gay men.

Like I said before, she is a forced and unnecessary character. I do not dislike her because she is a girl, I dislike her because she is literally forced into every aspect of the show with little reason. Weren`t you just say couple lines before that u dislike her because she is female? Yet you called this show gay, which is completly misunderstanding.

First line- excuuusee me, but aside of discussion about how much gay this anime is, females  are not allowed to be shown in shonen-ai series? Like heck they are in coed highschool, it would be weird if there weren`t interact with any girl. Adding female character, who they can befriend with makes this series a little more believable.

Second- no reason for her to be in this anime? Forced? Are we watchin the same show? She is Rin sis- she was the one who cause Rin and co to meet, since she send her bro SMS about their whereabouts. Like seriously, it`s thanks to her that they decide to make this swimming club in first place. And why is she unnecessary? As far she shown to be very competent club menager, makes the effort to improve on their training by setting up the team's regimen and organizing joint swimming practices. Is that unnecessary? I don`t think that any of them would be capable of this function so far.

Mary Sue? You even know what it means? She has 2 weakness so far (3 if you count the Kou/Gou thing)- muscles and her bro. She is his sis and see that something bothers him, she want him to be happy like in old times. Her bro doesn`t even concern about her, but yeah, he is cool since he is a man in a gay anime :/. She adores well built men, like some people like to watch beautiful art (like Michelangelo`s David statue). Yeah, we all are like this if we face the truth. The reason she is so likeable is exactly that she isn`t overreactin one way or another (acting tsundere or being too shy to accept the complement), she is just normal teen girl, thats why so many people identify themselves with her.

And with all my respect for Ama- sensei, she isn`t that interesting. She is just ice cream koan to me right now (although maybe somethin change). The thing is that she appear less than Kou and looks like typical  airheaded, cute chicks I saw many times in other mangas and animes.

Lack of depth? Then u will call every fangirl like that, just because she is oogling over men`s body? Is it because she doesn`t act tsundere everytime she is around men? So far she shown strong will and dilligence in helping boys with their swimming club, thats built her personality. Harem trope character? As far I didn`t see that she would be interested romantically in any of boys (beside their muscles). About lack of depth, I`m curious why nobody complain about Nagisa, since he is nothin more than cute shota trait. Ah wait, I know why- because he is a man in a gay anime again.

But its ok for people to have their opinions.

EVEN THOUGHT THEY`RE F***IN WRONG.