Thread:Luxartisan/@comment-5785681-20190530065703/@comment-27869316-20190603153013

Ok so first up, I agree with what Tari said about Music being a primary category in the Top Nav thread and thus adjusting its categorisation withing the tree, I think it shoudl stay under Related Media like Books/Drama CDs/etc. because otherwise like the issue with categorizing characters it would maybe come off as implying the music related stuff is more important than the other media which is untrue it's just probably the most popular section out of all the related media.

I apologise if it seems like this issue has come out of nowhere for you Angelle, when I first mentioned it I hadn't intended for it to become a big problem I was just worried about superfluously categorising things more than they need (which is still something I'd very much like to avoid) because I know that this can hoenstly hinder user navigation rather than help, which is the intention. I would've brought it up in previous discussions but in all honesty my original concept for how category trees were applied to articles appears to be somewhat different from your own so I hadn't realised 100% that this is how it would occur, which is my mistake. On a previous wiki that uses trees rather than applying all upper categories that came before a subcat we only applied the one immediately before, ie. for example the Drama CDs category would only have the CDs category applied rather than Formats, Related Media & CDs. As such, I hadn't thought of some the primary categories as being a particular issue because at the time I didn't think they would be applied all the way down, even after I realised that you had meant to apply it in this manner because I hadn't fully considered the impact that would have on certain articles and categories.

That being said, I'm not fully opposed to listing multiple categories since as you said its for search optimization, and I'm glad you agreed on the points regarding not applying anything above the specific characters category to the story/quote/etc pages and the episodes point that Yuji raised. However, considering you appreciate the logic behind those points could we also still leave off "Formats" and "CDs/Music CDs/Drama CDs/Radio CDs" off individual song and drama tracks, as similar to the character categories I just think that it would be illogical to apply those because the tracks themselves aren't a format or a CD and is therefore inappropriate to categorise them as such. Everything else mentioned by either myself or Yuji (with Yuji's agreement of course) though I'm happy to leave for now and just enact the tree as you've currently proposed and see how we go with that. If we feel though that certain categories and pages are still too cluttered though once we're done I think we should review those points again and see what we think.

(I apologise for not commenting on this thread yesterday but honestly Yuji had already fully conveyed what I felt and thought regarding your response to my last comment so I didn't think it would be beneficial for me to comment too as I had nothing new to add at that point particularly)

-Fox 15:30, June 3, 2019 (UTC)