Thread:Luxartisan/@comment-5785681-20190530065703/@comment-27869316-20190530144927

I figured it would be better for me to reply here rather then the previous thread since there's new stuff to respond to but re: the last few messages from you and Yuji on the old one:

-cool, I'm happy you were able to find out a way to work the tree so that those unneccessary cats don't have to be directly on the character page, how they've been applied to the other pages instead makes more sense imo, for now though I'll leave the adding of character categories to you and work on the re-categorising the music cause there's a lot and then maybe move onto books? Unless Yuji wanted to take one of those instead, I don't mind either way (also please tell me if I've categorised any of the ones I'm about to adjust incorrectly)

-Eliminating male/female/non-binary seems reasonable to me since yeah the cast is overwhelmingly male that it wouldn't make site navigation any easier and it specifies their gender in the infobox anyway so it's not like we've failed to present the info somewhere on the page

-For the badges, I can maybe attempt a new template, where would we want it to sit on the page though? If it comes before the infobox we might run into the same problem we're currently trying to fix

For the new stuff on this V3 thread (also don't worry you're not being presumptive, or at least I don't think so):

-The only tweak I can see for the tree is adding in the subcats for the books if that's possible, so like with some of the other subcats I've separated them into which series/movie they belonged to and then having the individual books listed under that kinda like the music -

++Related Media

+++Books

++++Free! Books

individual titles listed (this follows for all following subcats)

++++Free!-Eternal Summer- Books

++++High☆Speed！－Free! Starting Days－ Books

++++-Timeless Medley- Books

++++Free!-Dive to the Future- Books (currently i haven't designated one for RttW since they haven't announced any books for it yet, but I'm assuming we'll have to add that here at some point in the future)

Also under the music CDs section, for the character CDs I'm making categories for each CD and these cats will be applied to the song articles for the songs from that CD like with the Drama CDs and their tracks, I forgot to include that in a previous message I think, my apologies

-As for the final list for character classification, I updated the list on my original blog post so that should be the final one (for the moment, as discussed) as per our consensus, assume any character not listed belongs under minor unless I've forgotten someone super important in which case please tell me lol

-As for the superior cats regarding schools and whatnot, if by superior cats here you mean ones like "Swim Organizations", "Schools", "Locations", etc? If so, I feel like adding those to character articles might be a bit... confusing, I guess? Because that would imply that the character is a location/organization which is not true, they're simply affiliated with that place in some significant manner

Edit: similar to my last point, I'm also inclined to argue that we should leave off the Formats category on individual article pages within that over-arching category ie. not applying it to the individual book articles, since the individual books/movies/songs/etc. in and of themselves are not a format, but one of the categories they belong to is a format and should therefore have that category applied to it. So, for example "Music" should absolutely have the "Format" category, but "GOLD EVOLUTION" as a song should not, does that make sense?

Secondary Edit: For pages like the image galleries and chapter pages on certain book articles, how should those be categorised do we think? At the moment the galleries just have the cat "Image Gallery" and chapters has "Novel" & "Plot", Novel has been replaced by Books on the main article but should plot remain and if so what other cats would be necessary in these instances?

-Fox 14:49, May 30, 2019 (UTC)