Thread:Luxartisan/@comment-27869316-20190602165430/@comment-5785681-20190609015314

Still having issues with the following subcats not linking. IDK if it's my computer or the links:

Supporting and Minor Character Seiyū subcats and Supporting and Minor Character English VAs subcats

Also...with the added tags of High School Students and University Students, we've created two new subcats. Do we want to add them to the tree? It's classifies the new characters, which is helpful, but it does add more subcats. Where would they fit, if at all? It's up to us.

My other question is my earlier one about how characters appear on the Main Character Category page. I really liked the breakdown by affiliation and found it tremendously useful before the new Top Nav was created because it helped with search, but now, I think this idea can be offered as a Specialty Page within the Characters category. It could be called a "Quick Guide to Affiliations" or some such and be a fun reference page while the regular index provides simple search.

The other reasons I prefer straight indexing are: 1. It matches all the other category pages, thus unifying the wiki's appearance; 2. It gives Users a choice of how they wish to view the listing -- Alphabetical or by Most Visited; and 3. It doesn't give misleading impressions about the importance of characters via visual representation. For example: using the affiliations page as a guide to Characters gives Chris and David from the Australian Swim Club equal billing to Rin while Haruka is down the page with "Hidaka University" and Makoto is listed as an "Other" character. This doesn't seem right to me. Just as we saw placement of the Music category as needing to be subordinate in appearance to the Primary cats, I think the same visual rule applies here.

How do you feel about these issues?

And btw, I plan to leave a more personal message on my blog soon.

 Angelle ( Talk ) 01:53, June 9, 2019 (UTC)