Thread:Saruhikofushimis/@comment-5785681-20190819201228/@comment-27869316-20190827152944

All input from semi-regular users is welcome here P.H. CP ^^ so thank you for your input

I think it would be polite to wait a little while and see if Tari comments here, but if not it would probably be safe to assume she stands by that comment you quoted. Given she said she'd be away for three weeks or so, does mid-September seem like a reasonable deadline for a decision?

In the meantime, there are a few very minor issues I personally would like to discuss about your editing before I'd be comfortable definitely voting yes, not only on my own behalf but Yuji's now too.

-Duplicate images: I've noticed it happening less frequently lately, however there was a recent concerning trend in you repeatedly uploading images that already existed on the wiki. This creates additional work for me as I have to delete the duplicates and clean up the associated pages/galleries.

-Image names: I believe this has been brought up before by Yuji (and myself, possibly) in that quite a few of the images you've uploaded have titles that dont accurately reflect the images content or are otherwise confusing (ie. magazine covers simply called otomedia cover.jpg when otomedia has produced probably well over 10+ different covers featuring free!). Again, this has been happening less lately but I thought it would be wise to bring it up again because there are still some images from time to time that I have had to rename or will do so at some point in the future.

-Article phrasing: possibly the biggest concern of the three, is that some of your large chunks of writing in articles can come across as quite informal; more like the writing was intended for a blog post than a proper article. Generally speaking article content should be third person, informal and strictly factual akin to writing an academic paper.

As I said, they are only minor in the overall scheme of things but given the level of trust and authority placed with a bureaucrat I think its necessary to address even small issues to try and minimize further problems down the track and help the wiki run as smoothly as possible. If any of this has sounded in any way harsh I apologise as that is not the intention, but I'm aware that in the past my wording of issues hasn't always been perfect, I'm just trying to be thorough.

-Fox 15:29, August 27, 2019 (UTC)